If you’ve ever had a kidney stone, you probably want to do whatever you can to avoid another one. But what if something as simple as adding Crystal Light to your water could actually help?
It might sound strange, but lemonade and other citrus drinks are recommended for preventing kidney stones, and there’s a reason for that.
“Certain citrus-flavored drinks contain citrate, which can make it harder for some types of kidney stones to form,” says Varnel Antoine, MD, with Hartford HealthCare Medical Group. “But whether it helps depends on the type of stone you form and what’s contributing to your risk.”
So is Crystal Light worth adding to your kidney stone prevention routine?
Citrate helps prevent some kidney stones
Kidney stones form when certain substances in your urine become concentrated enough to form crystals. The most common are calcium oxalate stones, and having too little citrate in your urine can increase your risk.
Citrate prevents stones by binding with calcium in the urine, leaving less calcium to combine with oxalate and form kidney stones.
“Citrate essentially helps keep certain stone-forming materials from sticking together,” says Dr. Antoine. “For someone who has low urinary citrate, increasing those levels can be an important part of preventing another stone.”
If your citrate levels are too low, your doctor might prescribe potassium citrate, but there are other options.
> Related: The 6 Best Ways to Prevent Kidney Stones, According to a Urologist
Can Crystal Light lemonade prevent kidney stones?
There’s a reason Crystal Light lemonade comes up in conversations about kidney stones.
The powdered lemonade contains both potassium citrate and sodium citrate, two ingredients that help increase citrate levels in your urine. It’s also sugar-free, making it an appealing alternative to regular lemonade for some.
Research has found that lemonade can increase urine citrate levels and also help people drink more fluids. But prescription potassium citrate generally has a stronger, more consistent effect.
One small study actually compared Crystal Light lemonade with prescription potassium citrate in people with low urinary citrate. The results suggest the drink affects urine chemistry, but the study was too small to draw definite conclusions.
“Something you can buy at the grocery store isn’t automatically equivalent to prescription potassium citrate,” says Dr. Antoine. “The amount of citrate matters, and we usually base treatment on someone’s individual urine testing.”
> Related: 3 Signs Your Back Pain Is Actually From Kidney Stones
The extra water may be helping too
There’s another benefit of Crystal Light that has nothing to do with the ingredient list: You’re drinking more fluids.
Staying hydrated is one of the most important things you can do to prevent kidney stones. The more urine you produce, the less concentrated those stone-forming substances become.
“If someone doesn’t enjoy plain water but will consistently drink flavored water, that can help them reach their fluid goals,” says Dr. Antoine. “For many kidney stone patients, increasing urine volume is one of the biggest things we’re trying to accomplish.”
So if Crystal Light helps you drink more fluids, it could be a useful option when it comes to preventing stones.
Want a Weekly Dose of Health News?
Not all Crystal Light flavors have the same ingredients
Before you stock up on Crystal Light, check the ingredients because different flavors have different lists.
For example, Crystal Light’s powdered lemonade contain both potassium citrate, and sodium citrate, while its liquid Classic Lemonade only has sodium citrate.
And just because a drink contains citric acid doesn’t mean it provides the same benefits as a therapeutic dose of citrate.
“People see the word ‘citrus’ or ‘citric acid’ and assume every lemonade product will have the same effect,” says Dr. Antoine. “But the formulation and amount of citrate can vary quite a bit.”
That’s why it’s worth asking your doctor what they actually want you to look for rather than relying on the flavor alone.
> Related: A Lemon a Day Could Keep Kidney Stones Away
Your kidney stone type matters
What works for one person’s kidney stones may not necessarily work for yours. That’s because different types of stones form for different reasons.
A 24-hour urine test can help your doctor figure out what’s putting you at risk, whether it’s your fluid intake, low citrate levels or another reason.
For people who form calcium-based stones, increasing citrate can be helpful. Citrate can also raise urine pH, which can help prevent certain uric acid stones.
“Kidney stone prevention works best when we know why you’re forming stones,” says Dr. Antoine. “A drink like Crystal Light may be useful for some patients, but it shouldn’t replace figuring out your individual risk factors.”