Choosing the right moisturizer comes down to one thing: matching the formula to your skin type. Use something too heavy and oily skin gets worse. Too light and dry skin stays dry.
But most people never figure this out because they grab whatever worked once and never switch.
“The biggest mistake I see is people using the same moisturizer their whole life without checking if it still fits their skin,” says Christelle Nimba, APRN, FNP-C, with Hartford HealthCare Medical Group.
Not sure what moisturizer is right for you? Here’s how to choose.
Virtual care - when and where you need it
1. Figure out your skin type before you buy a moisturizer
Most people fall into 1 of 5 skin types: normal, dry, oily, combination or sensitive. Knowing yours is important when it’s time to buy a moisturizer.
“Wash your face, wait 30 minutes, then check how it feels. That tells you most of what you need to know,” notes Nimba.
Tight or flaky skin usually means dry. Shiny all over usually means oily. Shine only in the T-zone usually means combination. Skin that reddens, stings or reacts to new products easily usually means sensitive. And if your skin feels comfortable and balanced all day, that is normal skin, which means almost any lightweight moisturizer will do the job.
> Related: Which SPF Sunscreen Should I Use?
2. Dry skin needs a thicker moisturizer
Dry skin has two things working against it. It loses moisture quickly and has a harder time replacing it. And a thin lotion often does not cut it.
“Look for a cream or ointment, since those hold more oil than a lotion and lock in hydration longer,” explains Nimba.
Ingredients like shea butter, ceramides and hyaluronic acid help repair a dry skin barrier. Ceramides rebuild the barrier itself, while hyaluronic acid pulls moisture in and helps it stay there. Applying while skin is still slightly damp after washing helps seal in even more.
> Related: What to Know Before You Buy Sunscreen This Summer
3. Oily skin still needs moisturizer
Oily skin gets worse with one common mistake. Skipping moisturizer entirely. Skin that feels stripped tends to compensate by producing even more oil.
“You don’t need an expensive formula for oily skin,” adds Nimba. “Some of the best options cost under $15 at any drugstore. Price has almost nothing to do with how well it works.”
Look for a lightweight gel or water-based lotion and the word noncomedogenic on the label, which means it is designed not to clog pores.
Want a Weekly Dose of Health News?
4. Combination skin may need more than 1 moisturizer
Combination skin needs two formulas, not one. Your face is oily in some spots and dry in others, usually with the T-zone (forehead, nose and chin) running oily while the cheeks stay dry. One product rarely covers both well.
“I tell patients to use a lighter gel on the T-zone and a richer cream on the cheeks,” continues Nimba.
It takes an extra 30 seconds but makes a real difference in how skin holds up through the day.
> Related: Should I Wear Sunscreen in the Winter?
5. Less is more with sensitive skin
Sensitive skin has one rule that matters more than any other. Keep the ingredient list short. The more additives in a formula, the more chances for a reaction.
“Fragrance-free and hypoallergenic products with ingredients like colloidal oatmeal or aloe tend to be the safest choice,” shares Nimba.
Patch test any new moisturizer on your inner arm for at least 48 hours before putting it on your face.
> Related: 4 Skin Rashes to Watch Out for This Summer
6. Your skin type can shift up to four times a year
Your skin type is not fixed. It can shift up to four times a year as the seasons change, which means the formula that works in August may not work in January.
“I remind patients to reassess their routine when seasons change,” reminds Nimba. “Winter usually calls for something richer. Summer often means going lighter.”
Switching to a heavier cream in cold months and a lighter gel in warm ones is a simple adjustment most people skip but one most skin actually needs.
