Why Heart Patients Shouldn’t Use Apple Watch to Detect AFib

Apple Watch
Print icon

Seems that the Apple smartwatch can do it all – check email, send an SOS, connect to your car, get directions, open your garage door and order a pizza — but checking your heartbeat for atrial fibrillation might not make sense.

Dr. Steven Zweibel, director of electrophysiology at the Hartford HealthCare Heart & Vascular Institute, said the Apple watch’s newest application, recently approved for limited use by the Food and Drug Administration, has the potential to cause more anxiety, healthcare-related costs and even harm for patients who may not even have a problem at all by subjecting them to unnecessary treatments.

The application can take a recording of the wearer’s heart rhythm, known as an electrocardiogram (EKG), and detect AFib, or a rapid or skipped heartbeat.

While that sounds like a great help for people who have or are at risk for AFib – which is known to cause fatigue, dizziness or chest pain and can otherwise go undetected – Dr. Zweibel said the danger lies in the false positive readings the app will certainly generate.

“The risk to benefit ratio is not yet proven,” he said. “My concern is that there are too many variables. The average person who buys an Apple watch is not our patient age 65 or higher with risks of cardiac disease. It’s more the lower-risk population with a much lower incidence of AFib.”

Dr. Zweibel says the condition only occurs in 1 or 2 percent of the population under the age of 65, but if the watch notices a disconnect between the wearer’s activity and his or her heart rate — no matter the person’s age — it can send an alert about the possibility that the wearer is in AFib. That, Dr. Zweibel predicted, will possibly lead to significant anxiety and emergency doctor’s appointments to be checked.

“The Apple watch is approved for monitoring heart rhythms,” he said. “It specifically states during device setup that it is not to be used in patients with known AFib.”

As one who wears the watch himself, Dr. Zweibel said Heart & Vascular Institute cardiologists recommend that people with AFib get a different type of wearable device to monitor their heartbeat. The device attaches to their smartphone and is used with an accompanying application. The user can open the app and place their fingers on the pad attachment to the phone. The device then records a single-lead EKG that can be read by the company and sent along to the wearer’s doctor for any necessary follow up.

To use these devices – or an Apple watch app – for screening would require defining the population that should be screened because he said it should not be anyone sporting the watch itself.

Once clearly identified, however, people meeting certain criteria can benefit greatly from wearables tracking biometric data like heart rates, blood pressure and blood sugar levels. These will eventually, he hoped, be pulled from the wearable device into the person’s medical chart and messages sent to appropriate providers when needed.

“There is a lot of potential for gathering information from our patients and we are looking into the use of artificial intelligence to process data and alert doctors about problems,” Dr. Zweibel said. “But, we need to be realistic about what the Apple watch app is because it could open Pandora’s Box.”

For more information about the Heart & Vascular Institute and atrial fibrillation, click here

What's New

Tallwood Men’s Health: Heart Health

Heart disease is the leading cause of death for men in the United States and worldwide. For the man who regularly consults with his doctor, however, heart disease and its potentially fatal consequences are usually avoidable. Dr. Waseem Chaudhry is a preventive cardiologist at the Hartford HealthCare Tallwood Men’s Health Center....

Heart Failure: A New Level of Concern with Preserved Ejection Fraction

Heart failure is an extremely serious condition – but there are treatments. Plus, there’s a not-well-known condition called heart failure with preserved ejection fraction. Dr. Abhishek Jaiswal is a cardiologist with the Center for Advanced Heart Failure with the Hartford HealthCare Heart & Vascular Institute. Q: What is heart failure...

Babies in Red Hats: Raising Awareness of Congenital Heart Defects

Pictured above: Angelica Otero of Willimantic holds her new baby boy Joeziah Cummings Otero who was born Jan. 26 at the Windham Hospital Birthing Center. They may not be aware of it quite yet, but babies born at Hartford HealthCare hospitals in February are taking part in their own effort to...

Thoracic Outlet Syndrome

How Pain in Her Shoulder Became Thoracic Outlet Syndrome

Veronica Debkiewicz was just a few months shy of earning her nursing degree when she lost feeling and function in her right arm. “I woke up with a lot of pain in my shoulder,” said Debkiewicz, who now works as a perioperative nurse at Hartford Hospital. “It felt like my...

Detection and Treatment for Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm

Abdominal aortic aneurysm – commonly known as “triple A” – is often referred to as the silent killer. But a simple, 10-minute screening for this condition along with early intervention have proven to be lifesaving. Vascular surgeon Dr. Akhilesh Kumar Jain from the Hartford HealthCare Heart & Vascular Institute explains....