Can too much exercise be bad for your heart?

Print icon

There is certainly no doubt that exercise is good for you. To improve overall cardiovascular health, The American Heart Association recommends at least 150 minutes per week of moderate exercise (such as brisk walking) or 75 minutes per week of vigorous exercise (such as jogging) or a combination of moderate and vigorous activity. But, are there dangers in exercising too much? 

Dr. Paul Thompson, Chief of Cardiology and the Athletes’ Heart Program at Hartford Hospital, has been collaborating with scientists at the Radboud University Medical Center in the Netherlands to find an answer that question.  The group released a review of the topic in 2016 entitled “Are There Deleterious Cardiac Effects of Acute and Chronic Endurance Exercise?,” which Thompson presented while receiving an  Honorary Fellowship in the Royal College of Physicians of Ireland on Sept. 17.

The answer lies somewhere in the middle, Thompson says.

“According to epidemiological studies, when you’ve reached the Heart Association’s recommended levels, you’ve maximized the cardiovascular benefit,” says Thompson, a former elite marathoner who was a qualifier for the 1972 U.S. Olympic Marathon Trials and finished 16th in the Boston Marathon in 1976.  “Anything more than that you’re doing for some other reason—to win a race, or maybe help battle depression.”

Thompson admits it’s difficult to come to any finite conclusions about possible dangers of too much exercise because there simply aren’t enough people on the far end of the exercise curve.

“There are very few people who run for two hours a day or cycle for three hours a day.  But they do exist,” he says.

Some of the findings might be of some concern to hardcore endurance athletes.  First, Thompson says atrial fibrillation, an abnormal heart rhythm characterized by rapid and irregular beating of the atria, appears to be more common among distance runners.

“We don’t know exactly why this happens. We think it’s because exercise increases the heart chambers, and the bigger the heart chambers, the greater the chance of A Fib,” Thompson says.

Another trait found in lifelong endurance athletes is a build-up of calcium in the coronary arteries.

“Life Long endurance athletes have more calcium than we would expect.  Some have so much calcium that it looks like they have arteriosclerosis (the hardening or narrowing of the arteries),”  Thompson says.

Thompson says he’s not sure why this is but believes it might be related to the observation that exercise increases parathyroid hormone which regulates calcium levels in blood and tissues. While more calcium build-up means a greater risk for heart attack, if it’s particularly thick it can actually be more stable and protective, he says.  Calcium can be detected through a coronary calcification scan, a special X-ray to check for buildup.

“What’s interesting about these athletes is that they not only have a lot of calcium but they have a lot of dense calcium.  So, what they might actually be doing is creating safe, stable plaques in the coronary arteries. This is an important area of research and investigation,” Thompson says.

Thompson also says some endurance athletes have been found to have tiny scars where the right and left ventricle intersects.

While he expects the findings might cause alarm for some endurance athletes, Thompson says it’s too early to make any definite conclusions.

“The bottom line, endurance athletes—runners, rowers, cyclists—live longer than regular people,” Thompson says.  “It’s a chicken or the egg scenario.  Do they live longer because of the exercise or do they live longer because they were just born with better genes that make them endurance athletes? We don’t know for sure, but it’s a fun area of research and has clinical importance when taking care of endurance athletes.  I see runners and cyclists from all over the country who come here because they know of our interest in this topic.”

Learn more at the Hartford HealthCare Heart & Vascular Institute.


What's New

Cancer cells.

Dr. Wylie Hosmer: Weaponizing Your Immune System Against Cancer

By Dr. Wylie D. Hosmer The three most terrifying words in the English language may be: “You have cancer.” But exciting advances in research have uncovered more powerful treatment options, using the patient’s immune system, to target and attack cancer cells. More research is needed, but this treatment known as...


Child Car Seat Safety: Installation is Key

Did you know that accidents – including car accidents – are the leading cause of children’s deaths? Child safety seats can reduce death by as much as 71 percent and prevent injury but only if they are used correctly, according to Safe Kids Connecticut. Connecticut law requires that all children...

Woman taking out trash.

Is Taking Out The Trash Any Way To Live Longer? (Really?)

Thanks to fitness-tracker accelerometers, researchers have learned more precisely the amount of physical activity it takes to live a longer, fitter life. Surprisingly, not much. Three studies that used accelerometers to measure participants’ activity  concluded in recent months that even the lightest regular physical activity — making a bed, taking...

IV bags.

How Hurricane Maria Caused Nationwide IV Bag Shortage

With a nationwide shortage of intravenous bags, clinical pharmacies across Hartford Healthcare are working to ensure patient care isn’t interrupted. The Wall Street Journal reported that the shortage began in September after a group of IV bag manufacturing plants in Puerto Rico lost power because of Hurricane Maria. The shortage...

Man with flu.

The ‘Man Flu’: A Severe Case or Severe Wimpiness?

When it comes to complaining about flu and other upper-respiratory infection symptoms, men might not be wimps after all.  Maybe. A new study by researchers at Memorial University of Newfoundland in Canada found that “man flu” — a term often used by women who think that men complain more about...