Natural Weight-Loss Supplements to Avoid

Pills on a plate.
Print icon

Have you considered trying natural weight-loss supplements?

There is no shortage of products that promise to melt away the pounds, but how do you find the best one? It’s difficult because many weight-loss supplements are produced by the very people selling the product. So it’s important to gather unbiased and current information about the weight-loss pills available. Speak to your health-care provider.

Herbal or natural supplements that claim to help you lose weight come from plant sources.  These herbal supplements are often labeled “100% Natural” or “Healthy.” Because a product is natural doesn’t mean it is safe. And just because a supplement is “healthy” doesn’t mean it is effective.

Several recent studies on dietary supplements found that consumers who buy herbal supplements may not get the product advertised on the label. The state of New York has cited several large retailers for selling products that were not as advertised.

Here are the three most common herbal supplements I’m asked about to assist with weight loss:

Garcinia Cambogia

Even though it is one of the most popular products on the market, unfortunately, the herbal supplement has been shown to have “little to no effect on weight loss,” according to, among others, the National Institutes of Health Office of Dietary Supplements, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center and the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health.

Green Tea Extract

This herbal supplement is found on almost every drugstore shelf. Unfortunately, many research studies that investigated the extract’s effectiveness have not been high quality. You may not experience side effects if you drink green tea or take a green tea supplement but the NIH suggests that green tea may only provide a modest weight loss benefit, if any at all.

Raspberry Ketone

Another popular herbal supplement: But there have been no high-quality studies to demonstrate it’s effectiveness for weight loss. No serious side effects have been reported but this diet aid may harm your budget because there is little evidence to show that it actually helps you lose weight

On the flip side, some ingredients in over-the-counter diet products are known to cause harm and the Food and Drug Administration warns not to use.

Examples of these products:

  • Ephedrine is the main active ingredient of herbal ephedra.  The FDA does not allow the sale of medicines that contain ephedrine or ephedra due to serious side effects, including strokes and heart attacks.
  • BMPEA is a stimulant related to amphetamines. Supplements with the herb Acacia rigidula labeled on the packaging often contain BMPEA . This chemical can lead to health problems such as dangerous high blood pressure, heart rhythm problems, memory loss and mood problems.
  • DMBA and DMMA are stimulants that are similar chemically. They have been found in fat-burning and workout supplements. DMBA is also known as AMP citrate. Both chemicals can cause nervous system and heart problems.

Bottom Line

Before you take any supplement, be sure to consult your health care provider to make sure that the product is safe for you to use.

 

Dr. Devika Umashanker is an Obesity Medicine Specialist at Hartford Healthcare Medical Group.


What's New


Men: ED Treatment Sound Too Good To Be True? It Probably is.

If you were among the 50 percent of adult males between the ages of 40 and 70 with erectile dysfunction, would you pay thousands of dollars for shock-wave treatment, which has uncertainties about long-term effectiveness and safety? Would you be concerned that it is not FDA-approved? You should be. More...


Rx for Health Program Adds Healthy Options for Winter Season

Thanks to a partnership with the Norwich ShopRite and United Community and Family Services (UCFS), Backus Hospital’s successful Rx for Health Program to help fight childhood obesity is now available during the winter months. Nine years ago, staff at the hospital identified obesity as a top health concern as part...


Radiation Safety: What You Need to Know Before Imaging Tests

If your physician orders imaging services for you — whether X-ray, MRI, CT Scan or PET scan — you might wonder how safe is it to be exposed to radiation. Radiation safety is an important part of the health care process, closely regulated by medical physicists. At Hartford HealthCare, that...


Weight Loss? Improved Sleep? Yes, After This Free Diabetes Prevention Program.

Weight loss, improved sleeping, fewer medical problems and feeling better overall are among the benefits participants are reporting after completing the Southington Community YMCA’s free Diabetes Prevention Program, a 12-week series incorporating health education and exercise. The Southington Community YMCA, in collaboration with Hartford HealthCare, has been offering the program since...