Death By Distance Running? How The Human Heart Responds To Exercise

Print icon

It’s never too late to start a moderate exercise regimen in out-of-shape America. But Dr. Paul Thompson, chief of cardiology and co-physician-in-chief of the Hartford HealthCare Heart & Vascular Institute, has spent much of his professional life studying effects on runners who perhaps exercise too much.

“It looks like you get the most benefit from exercise when you go from nothing to something,” he said during a recent appearance on FoxCT. “The question is if there are increasing problems if people do too much exercise.”

Dr. Thompson, himself a runner with a 30-marathon resume that includes a 2:28:25 time in the 1972 Boston Marathon, published a study in 1979 on 18 men and women who died while running or immediately. Thirteen of the runners showed signs of heart disease. A 2011 Swedish study showed that males entered in a marathon cross-country ski race who had either completed the race the most times in the previous decade or finished with the fastest times were more likely than others to develop atrial fibrillation. (A-fib, when the heart’s upper chambers beat out of sync with the lower chambers,  increases the risk of stroke by up to 500 percent.)

The cause of death by exercise is defined clearly by age, says Dr. Thompson.

“If you’re over the age of 35,” he said, “it’s almost always narrowing of the coronary arteries from cholesterol.”

About 30 percent of them had previous symptoms, he said.

“A lot of them ignore chest discomfort,” Dr. Thompson said. “One of the things that’s ignored most frequently is discomfort in the top of the stomach. People think they’re having an ulcer or they’ve got heartburn — but that’s your heart until you prove it otherwise. So check it out with your physician.”

The death of younger runners during exercise is most often caused by congenital conditions of the heart muscle or coronary arteries. The hearts of serious athletes even look different. They’re larger and, because each beat injects more blood, the heart rate is slower.

“We don’t think that’s deleterious or dangerous in any way,” said Dr. Thompson.

A study of former Olympians earlier this year, in fact, showed that changes in the size of a serious runner’s heart do not cause long-term damage to the heart. The potential health benefits of exercising regularly, it turns out, overwhelm any possible dangers.

Hear that, out-of-shape America?

Most people prepared to run a marathon should not have a second thought, said Dr. Thompson. It’s the sedentary population that’s at greater risk of heart disease.

“Overexercise is not our problem in the United States,” he said. “Even standing up during the day reduces your risk of heart disease.”


What's New

Three people jogging on road, winter background.

Don’t Let Winter Freeze Your Exercise Routine: Here’s How

As the cold weather and snow begins to arrive in New England it’s time to start thinking of ways to keep exercising throughout the winter months.  As Dayle Stark, DPT (doctorate of physical therapy) from Hartford HealthCare Rehabilitation Network explains, there are many ways to remain active no matter what...

Gifts for the Kitchen

A Dietitian’s Good-for-You Holiday Gift Guide

As the days count down, are you still looking for meaningful gifts for those few left on your holiday shopping list? I try to consider gifts that can make 2020 more healthy and productive.  Maybe a couple of these ideas will pique your interest enough to check out further. For...


Hartford HealthCare Names First Connecticut Courage Award Winners

At the age of 15, University of New Haven football team senior running back Chris Liggio lost both his parents in a murder-suicide. Taylor Herd, a senior guard on the Quinnipiac University women’s basketball team, suffered two ACL tears in the same knee in high school, and her father has...

Healthy Diet

Cancer Survivors: Find The Power of a Healthy Diet

By Diane Avino Dietitian Gray Cancer Center Hartford HealthCare Cancer Institute at Hartford Hospital Eating well is important during all stages of life, but it’s particularly important for cancer survivorship. Adequate nutrition is a crucial part of staying well through cancer treatments as well as promoting your long-term health. Eating...

Immunotherapy

As Cancer Treatment Evolves, a Focus on Reducing Side Effects

By Dr. Omar Eton Melanoma DMT Lead Hartford HealthCare Cancer Institute Over the past two decades, there has been great progress in understanding the relationship between cancer and the defenses a patient can muster against it. This led to a Nobel Prize for James P. Allison and Tasuku Honjo in...

Stomach Cancer

Stomach Cancer: Signs You Shouldn’t Ignore

By Dr. Bret Schipper Chief of Surgical Oncology The Hospital of Central Connecticut and MidState Medical Center Stomach, or gastric, cancer in the United States is somewhat rare, but it’s important to know the signs and symptoms. According to the American Cancer Society, about 27,500 cases of stomach cancer will...

How the mind reacts to tragedy.

How the Mind Responds to Endless Bad National News

Two shootings in two days at military bases in Hawaii and Florida barely made the evening news, and these tragedies didn’t result in much water cooler talk, either. Is this the new normal? Not necessarily, according to Dr. Anthony Ng, medical director of the Hartford HealthCare Behavioral Health Network’s East...